by chrondog Mon Dec 05, 2016 6:17 pm
the Ghost Ship fire is truly truly sad. i'm glad none of my friends were there. it seemed like a very cool venue, though obviously unsafe.
i've seen a lot of weird takes on the tragedy from people on Facebook and the media at-large. the reality is that the economics of these "underground venues" don't make any sense, especially in the Bay Area with astronomical rents and a bevy of regulations on buildings. that's why they cut corners and aren't properly permitted. while artists would like to see the municipal government more involved in supporting safe, underground venues because 'artists make up the quirky character of the cities we love', i think the reality is actually that these artists and venues are very niche and the vast majority of the taxpaying public aren't interested in subsidizing art on any level. it's an intractable problem. cities aren't interested in affordable housing, flexible venue regulations, and subsidizing cultural events. they're in the business of gentrifying everything to increase the tax base, especially in Oakland. that's why these venues and these people have to go "underground".
it's very sad and these cold, hard, economically-motivated decisions don't reflect my personal values, but the truth is this tragedy is part of the risk that is taken on to bring these beautiful experiences to the people who want them, often those more on the margins of society. i honor their terrible, unfortunate sacrifice.
also, i think it's worth noting that the city is probably aware of most of these venues and the dangers they post. there are a TON of unpermitted venues in Oakland especially. but the city also tacitly accepts them. so they shouldn't be allowed to feign ignorance and say "well they didn't have the permits! we didn't know this could happen!" they say that because they don't want to be held legally responsible, obviously, but they're not absolved of all responsibility.